.: bio

 

 .: our blogs

 

 .: links
 Up on the wrong side of the bed.

Published - Wednesday, July 16, 2008

POST COMMENT | READ COMMENTS (5 comment(s))

Finie, Julius C.

.
Well, at long last the Julius C. Wilkie has been reduced to flinders and toothpicks -- albeit rotten flinders and toothpicks.

It wasn't Winona's finest hour.

I can't say I had any great love for the boat-shaped building at the foot of Main St. It was a Disneyfied misconception of a remarkable era; a structure that was neither historic nor contemporary with as close to an anti-functional design as has ever been foisted upon a good intentioned community.

Built on the cheap, haphazardly maintained, never open and forever in the red it was a only a matter of time until the whole edifice collapsed in upon itself. A few hours and a backhoe finally put it out of its misery.

But the tragedy that finally played itself out last week had little to do with bad plans and poor lumber. After the original Wilkie\Pierson burned, the Winona community rallied to replace what had been lost. People dug deep, writing checks and tossing change into collection buckets sitting at virtually every checkout counter in town. Winona invested money and spirit in what was promised to be a lasting representation of their heritage ... and Winona was badly shortchanged.

But at long last it's all over, but for carting away the rubble. Hardly a good, definitely not a happy, ending. But an ending.

Let's learn from it.
.
 Tell us what you think...

 Comments »

Troller wrote on Jul 21, 2008 3:11 PM:

" Maybe we should erect a plaque which says, "Here once stood a symbol of heritage, progress and human failing. Remember the river and your past for what it means to you and may the future be merciful to the river and our generation as it writes another chapter". Now, make this sign out of treated lumber and place it high enough Winona's little spray can artists need a ladder to deface it. Oh yes, and I still recommend a canoe on top as a "floating" piece of history which can be demolished, after a few years of neglect, for a couple of ten spots. "

Sharon K .Sweazey wrote on Jul 19, 2008 4:44 PM:

" I cried my eyes out watching the demolition. I don't care what anyone says, even if the roof had caved in, we still had something no other city has. I will miss it.

I worked very hard with a lot of other people trying to keep the ole girl a float. It should have been watched more closely during construction. It was my home for a long time trying to make it go. It never had a chance with the poor construction.

I also made many fond memories there. My son was married there, I had a cousin Stacey that had a lovely wedding shower there and I met Dr. Younger, Lee Luebbe, and Arlene Prosen.

I guess the boat can be torn down but the memories and friends I hold will never go away. "

Frank Schnurstein wrote on Jul 15, 2008 4:52 PM:

" Another museum is a step backwards. Let's return the levee to a park with a nice pavilion serveing many people for many occasions. Let's visit the Thompson when it arrives. It has real history and maritime value. Visit the Maritime Museum that Winona already has, and the Historical Society. But let's leave the levee open for all to enjoy with little maintenance and no staffing problems. In other words, we have been down that road and it didn't work. A building shaped like a boat does not represent our history but rather our inability to promote better spots to visit in Winona. If we are allowed to do so, with little effort I can visualize a coffee shop or small restaurant aboard the Thompson as well as a gift shop and other quarters filled with maritime history, legend and lore. "

Riverboatman wrote on Jul 15, 2008 12:57 PM:

" Indeed, Winona exists BECAUSE of the river and the steamboats that plied it. Although the second WILKIE was not a real boat, it nonetheless REPRESENTED river history -- and future generations are going to be robbed of learning about that history if the prized artifacts from the boat and museum are stored away and never to be seen again. Here's hoping those who value Winona's river heritage get up steam and triumph in their determination to establish yet another river museum that would make Dr. Lewis I. Younger proud. "

Dieter Mielimonka wrote on Jul 14, 2008 11:54 PM:

" It would seem that if one looks for proof of whether the restoration of the Wilkie or the expansion of the Historical Society was of greater value or importance to the citizens of Winonsa, one only has to look at the monies contributed to each cause. "


The comments above are from readers. In no way do they represent the views of theRiver Valley Blogs.

 Post a comment (150 word limit) »

We will not post reader comments containing racial, religious or personal attacks, slander, profanity, e-mail addresses, mailing addresses, phone numbers or Web site addresses that are for personal or promotional gain.
(optional)
   
Thank you for your comments! Once your comments are approved, they will appear on the site.

 

 

Copyright © RVNG Publications | RVNG is a division of Lee Enterprises