.: bio

 

 .: our blogs

 

 .: links
 Jimmy Gillman

Published - Monday, November 24, 2008

POST COMMENT | READ COMMENTS (19 comment(s))

Dark subject will once again be front and center

.
When some movie theaters darken their lights this holiday season, it will be to make way for the largest number of films on a particularly dark subject released within weeks of one another in many years. No fewer than four films with Holocaust-related themes will confront moviegoers over the next few weeks, joining another three that have already been released this year. The question is whether there’s a reason for this cinematic anomaly, or if it is merely a coincidence.

Of course, the subject is always worthy of exploration, serving as a microcosm for all that is good and evil in the human experience. And films on the Holocaust are certainly not new to the horizon; many have been extremely successful with critics and audiences. Of the others, almost every one has been worthy of review.

I just find it interesting, without anything nefarious or inappropriate in mind, that seven films on the subject, each of which has been, and will be, well worth seeing, will have made their way to American movie screens in a single year -- a feat I can’t remember happening in a very long time, if ever. Is it because we face such serious times? Was there something particularly ominous happening a couple of years back when most (if not all) of these films got the green light? Will this many films showing at one time risk coloring the memory or history of the events? Will audiences once again respond?

Click here for more.
.
 Tell us what you think...

 Comments »

Michael Welch The Enemy Below Above And All Around... wrote on Nov 26, 2008 10:55 AM:

" Oh gee it's actually those who DON'T KNOW 'history' who are 'doomed' to make the wrong analogies is my experience. For example these feverish fantasies of Obama as a 'red' fascist prince are SO typical of the religious rightists and are why they are so often wrong in their political assessments of the future. They claim their fantasies MUST become reality because such apocalyptics confirm for them the twisted world view they embrace. I recognize these as per Freud as 'projections' of their own desires to create 'order' along some imaginary biblical line that will finally re: a future apocalypse 'wipe away' at last their 'enemies' of the 'left' and even of the 'right' -- say John McCain. It's a Sarah Palin world for them and she's the REAL fascist princess who's to bring the double sword for infidel and heathen... "

Izzy Fabin to Harsch wrote on Nov 26, 2008 9:22 AM:

" Yeah, yeah, yeah, and those who live under bridges with barnyard animals will continue to tear at the flanks of those who are intellectually superior. Cliches, and all that. blah blah blah. What is your point again? In English this time? I know, maybe making up another lie about me may be a good response? That may deflect everyones attention from the issues. "

Uncle Lee couldnt be prouder... wrote on Nov 26, 2008 9:06 AM:

" Nephew, a brilliant analysis of the American Empire..the new twist on colonialism. Our masters, instead of occupying another country forever, decided that by simply placing obedient puppets in power, US forces could be removed, with no detriment to the continuing exploitation. This, of course, is the ultimate goal in Iraq, though the Iraqi people are resisting. "

harsch wrote on Nov 26, 2008 3:36 AM:

" In fact, the cliche can be turned on its head: some who learn to well from history find new ways to repeat it. For instance, given that colonialism was no longer tenable, the American empire found that it was essentially repeatable through assassination and subsequent employment of agreeable clientele. "

harsch wrote on Nov 26, 2008 3:34 AM:

" Those who don't learn of the vacuity of cliches are bound to repeat them ad infinitum. Most people who don't learn history simply come across a little dim, but few are in a position to make history. The cyclical view of history has always had its appeal--and it IS artful, which is why Joyce latched onto the ideas of Vico; but though various aspects of history do have their parallels later in history (empires do tend to over-extend, for instance) it is more generally true that the flux of history throws up unprecedented circumstances (the Ottomans declined for entirely different reasons from those that beset the Romans). "

To Michael wrote on Nov 25, 2008 4:51 PM:

" Those who dont learn from history are doomed to repeat it. But, go ahead. Just laugh about it if that makes you more comfortable. "

Michael Welch He RISES... wrote on Nov 25, 2008 10:46 AM:

" More silliness from the right wing dings; the actual economic crisis arouses NO interest for them as they're completely flummoxed while their erstwhile but now NEVER more to be MENTIONED 'hero' George W is presiding over the most disastrous end to a presidency since poor Bert Hoover's or Harry Truman's or James Buchanan's. But they are nostalgically fantasizing their own secret Hitlerian dreams I see -- ex-'Hitler Jugend'? GOT to be 'Johnny-Tess'! RIGHT UP HIS UH his 'ALLEY' I'd say. I can see them all glazed eyed, replaying their old 'Cabaret' recordings -- ah the good old days! Overthrow Obama and establish ORDER! And Lincoln Rockwell, shot dead outside the laundromat, rises again as THE RELIGIOUS RIGHT's REAL CHRIST!... "

Ronnie Gossett to my anonymous stalker and tormentor wrote on Nov 25, 2008 9:45 AM:

" You're kidding, right? Ray Charles could see these things coming! "

To Ronnie Gossett wrote on Nov 24, 2008 10:31 PM:

" I know its not your real name but you really should go into predicting earthquakes! You seem to know so much about the future and your so good with "hunches". "

Starfish wrote on Nov 24, 2008 7:03 PM:

" A dear friend, a friend whom I would describe as idiosyncratic but NOT daft, always warns of The Big Idea. Anyone who has an idea so large and enveloping that everyone must subscribe--Christianity, Islam, capitalism, nationalism, narcissism--is to be feared. AT THIS MOMENT, we have a rather awesome confluence of Big Ideas playing out on the global stage. Before we do anything drastic as The World's Dominant Nation State, we should carefully--carefully!--examine all the human angles of one of the last similar moments. "

Hahahahahaha wrote on Nov 24, 2008 5:01 PM:

" Hey, Ronnie--didya just wake up after the last eight years? In case you missed it, your beloved GOP helped the President help the Executive Branch to extraordinary powers with signing statements, wiretapping, extraordinary rendition, etc. etc. etc. Dude, the time for the tinfoil hat is long past... Oh, and while we're talking about government takeover of people's lives, howabout Terry Schaivo? Gag rules? Or is that all okay the puppets of the Religious Wrong do it? "

Kizarny wrote on Nov 24, 2008 4:55 PM:

" Harsch, please yield. Our dear brother Izzy is a good man who only wants to challenge and to teach. Your wild, unfounded accusations and offbeat shenanigans are shameful. "

Harsch wrote on Nov 24, 2008 4:02 PM:

" As with Fabin and his over forty okay with under 15, this whole holocaust thing is in the eye of the beholder; I don't know what Fabin is getting at, but regarding the holocaust I think we all seem to have a similar repulsion yet artists think they might have a particular perspective. Many movies emerge. Great. Yet you get fantastic films like Polanski's and ask: Roman, why not a POLISH film? You get Spielgerg and the black and white but for the pink. What? I tell you, one of the great moments of my life was in Krakow when I vomited in the Spielberg bidet. But that's another story. "

Ronnie Gossett wrote on Nov 24, 2008 2:57 PM:

" I had never thought of that...ex Hitler youth makes an excellent point. Those who dont learn from history are doomed to repeat it. Some things to look out for: being jailed or fined for "hate" speech, hate crime enhancers, etc. We will see an increase in made up liberal words like homophobia, anti-marxism, marx-phobia, etc. "

ex-Hilter Youth Hilmar von Campe wrote on Nov 24, 2008 12:23 PM:

" "What I see in America today is people painting their cabins while the ship goes down. Today in America we are witnessing a repeat performance of the tragedy of 1933 when an entire nation let itself be led like a lamb to the Socialist slaughterhouse. This time, the end of freedom is inevitable unless America rises to her mission and destiny." From "Defeating the Totalitarian Lie: A Former Hitler Youth Warns America." "

Michael Welch Nuance At Nuremberg Also... wrote on Nov 24, 2008 10:29 AM:

" 'Judgment' also had a stellar cast with Maximilian Schell (who won the Oscar) as a young passionate and forceful defender of the nazi judges on trial whom he represented as basically victims of historical circumstance so to speak. Burt Lancaster was cast (as often) 'against type' as the most intellectual and reflective of the accused who delivers a monologue as per Tracy's that devastates the usual 'I knew nut-tink! Nut-tink!' sort of response that became even 'comic' in say Billy Wilder's 'divided Berlin' comedy 'One Two Three!' And Monty Cliff and Judy Garland as Jewish victims of prejudice both gave deeply moving but nuanced performances. Anti-nazi former German star Marlene Dietrich also provides the view of the 'patriotic' German. 'J at N' just remains for me the MOST intelligent 'explanation' for organized madness... "

Michael Welch The Rock-Ribbed Republican From Maine... wrote on Nov 24, 2008 10:19 AM:

" I suppose if one is to have a 'favorite' Jewish holocaust film mine is still the venerable but yet powerful 'Judgment at Nuremberg,' which was originally a television play by Abby Mann that he expanded for the 1961 Stanley Kramer production. I saw it in its appropriate black and white at the 'Bethany' theater in Phoenix, the same place I first viewed 'West Side Story' and 'The Road to Hong Kong' plus 'The Nun and the Sergeant.' Tracy as 'the rock-ribbed Republican' judge from the state o' Maine who 'thought Franklin Roosevelt was a great man' delivered perhaps the most eloquent argument for humane dignity in film. The old worn white haired thirties and forties star from then on, for me, represented the IDEAL quintessential American... "

Froto wrote on Nov 24, 2008 9:28 AM:

" Hmmmmmmmmm sounds like a plot by some fringe group overpowering the industry with money bribes. Who could it be?. The Dems the Repubs, the far side of either, or some new fanatical group lurking in the background? "

Cagefighter wrote on Nov 24, 2008 8:52 AM:

" I have seen two movies on the Holocaust and both were amazingly powerful. "Schindlers List" and "Life is Beautiful". The latter is one of the most amazing movies I have ever seen. I am normally not one for watching a movie with subtitles-but that was one compelling movie. The part where the main character and his family have been captured by the Nazis, and the doctor(whom was not Jewish but he thought was his friend) was talking about how he couldnt sleep because he couldnt figure out a riddle. You could see the look on his face when he realized what kind of a man the doctor really was. I recently read a commentary by Stephen King talking about his novella "Apt Pupil". His editor, who was Jewish, was upset King(a non-Jew) would write about the Holocaust. Kings response was that sometimes we write about something to learn about it. "


The comments above are from readers. In no way do they represent the views of theRiver Valley Blogs.

 Post a comment (150 word limit) »

We will not post reader comments containing racial, religious or personal attacks, slander, profanity, e-mail addresses, mailing addresses, phone numbers or Web site addresses that are for personal or promotional gain.
(optional)
   
Thank you for your comments! Once your comments are approved, they will appear on the site.

 

 

Copyright © RVNG Publications | RVNG is a division of Lee Enterprises